Uncovering the Value of Literary Education With Hollander: A Critical Analysis

Hollander argues that literary education holds significant value in shaping the minds and perspectives of individuals, serving as a fundamental pathway towards higher learning. He believes that through the study and analysis of literature, one's mind is conditioned to grasp and appreciate various subjects such as Philosophy, Psychology, Political Science, and beyond. By delving into the intricate narratives and rich symbolism found within literary works, individuals acquire critical thinking skills, develop empathy, and cultivate the ability to interpret complex ideas and themes. Through the exploration of diverse literary voices and perspectives, individuals become better equipped to engage with the world around them, fostering a deeper appreciation for the complexities of human experiences and facilitating personal growth.

What for Hollander Are the Flaws With a Purely Skills Based Approach to Teaching?

Hollander identifies several flaws with a purely skills-based approach to teaching, and central to her critique is the issue of emotional intelligence. While skills-based learning focuses primarily on acquiring technical abilities and knowledge, it often neglects the development of emotional aptitude. According to Hollander, this limitation poses a serious flaw in the Common Core educational philosophy, as it can result in the “dumbing down” of students minds.

Furthermore, by solely prioritizing skills, Hollander contends that educators risk perpetuating a narrow and utilitarian view of education. Emphasizing only technical proficiency can lead to a disregard for critical thinking, creativity, and problem-solving abilities that are integral to a well-rounded education. This not only limits students capacity for innovation but also restricts their ability to adapt and thrive in a rapidly changing world.

In Hollanders view, the exclusive focus on skills also neglects the importance of personal values, character development, and ethical decision-making. Education shouldn’t solely be about how to do things but also about why we do them and what impact our actions have on others and society as a whole. By neglecting this broader dimension of learning, a purely skills-based approach fails to equip students with the tools necessary to navigate complex moral and ethical dilemmas they may encounter in their lives.

Additionally, Hollander argues that a skills-based model can undervalue individual differences and diversity within the classroom. By narrowly defining success based solely on technical proficiency, students with alternative learning styles or differing strengths may face marginalization and be unfairly judged against a predetermined set of skills deemed as essential by the curriculum.

Watch this video on YouTube:

Moreover, teaching literature equips future educators with the ability to foster critical thinking, improve communication skills, and nurture empathy in their students. By engaging in deep analysis of literary works, students learn to consider multiple perspectives, question assumptions, and draw evidence-based conclusions. These skills are essential for success in various professions, where the ability to analyze complex information, communicate effectively, and understand diverse viewpoints is highly valued. Therefore, as a future educator, teaching literature isn’t simply about imparting knowledge; it’s about preparing students for a lifetime of learning and professional growth.

Why Is Teaching Literature Important as a Future Educator?

One of the reasons teaching literature is important as a future educator is that it helps students develop critical thinking skills. Analyzing a fictional text requires students to think deeply about the plot, characters, themes, and symbols within the story. They must learn to ask insightful questions and interpret the text in a thoughtful and meaningful way.

In addition, literature can teach students empathy and a deeper understanding of the human experience. By reading diverse stories from different time periods and cultures, students are exposed to a range of perspectives and experiences. They can learn to appreciate different viewpoints and gain a more nuanced understanding of the world around them. Empathy and understanding are crucial skills needed in any profession, as they help individuals connect with others and work collaboratively towards common goals.

Teaching literature can also foster creativity and imagination in students. Through reading and exploring fictional worlds, students can develop their own imagination and creativity. They learn to visualize scenes, create mental images of characters, and engage with the story in a personal and imaginative way. This creativity and imagination can then be applied to other aspects of their lives, whether it be problem-solving, storytelling, or innovation in their future careers.

Furthermore, teaching literature can improve students communication skills. Literature often provides rich material for discussion and analysis. Students are encouraged to express their thoughts, opinions, and interpretations, and engage in meaningful conversations with their peers. These discussions help students develop their ability to articulate ideas, listen to others, and engage in respectful dialogue. These communication skills will be valuable in any professional setting, where effective communication is essential for collaborating, presenting ideas, and expressing oneself clearly.

By exposing students to a wide range of literary works, teachers can introduce them to different genres, styles, and authors. This can ignite a passion for reading and open doors to a world of knowledge and exploration. Students who develop a love for reading are more likely to continue reading and learning beyond the classroom. This enthusiasm for learning can translate into a student who’s constantly seeking new knowledge and experiences, which can only benefit them in their future endeavors.

Moreover, literature plays a significant role in shaping the language skills of individuals. By exploring various literary works, learners can expand their vocabulary, improve their understanding of dialogues, and appreciate the rhythmic elements of poetry and prose. Furthermore, literature encourages critical thinking and analytical skills, allowing learners to analyze and interpret texts. It also exposes them to real-life situations and universal issues, motivating them to engage with the written word and further develop their language abilities.

How Does Literature Impact Language?

Literature has a profound impact on language by enhancing the communicative skills of learners. By immersing themselves in literature, learners are exposed to different linguistic patterns and structures, allowing them to expand their language proficiency.

Moreover, literature also plays a significant role in enhancing analytical skills. By analyzing various literary works, learners are exposed to complex ideas, themes, and narratives, which encourage critical thinking and the development of analytical skills. Literature requires readers to delve deeper into the text, to examine the motives of characters, and to decipher underlying messages, fostering a higher level of comprehension and interpretation.

Another way that literature impacts language is by familiarizing learners with universal issues and providing them with valuable insights into different cultures and perspectives. Literary works often touch upon timeless themes such as love, loss, identity, and power, and by exploring these themes, learners gain a broader understanding of the human condition. They’re exposed to diverse perspectives, allowing them to develop empathy and a more nuanced view of the world around them.

Furthermore, literature serves as a powerful motivator for reading. By exposing learners to well-crafted stories, relatable characters, and captivating narratives, literature sparks an interest in reading. This interest can then extend beyond the realm of literature, encouraging learners to explore other genres and forms of written expression. By cultivating a love for reading, literature has the potential to instill lifelong learning habits and a deep appreciation for language.

The Influence of Literature on Vocabulary Development: Discuss How Reading Literature Exposes Learners to New Words and Expands Their Vocabulary. Explore the Impact of Encountering Unfamiliar Words in Context and How It Aids in Language Acquisition.

Engaging with literature offers a rich opportunity for learners to encounter new words and broaden their vocabulary. Through reading, learners are exposed to a plethora of unfamiliar words, presented in the context of the story. This exposure to new vocabulary enhances language acquisition as readers are able to decipher word meaning based on the surrounding narrative. By encountering unfamiliar words in context, learners are able to make connections, infer meanings, and develop a deeper understanding of how words are used. Consequently, literature plays a vital role in expanding vocabulary and facilitating the development of language skills.

Source: How does literature influence language?..


By immersing oneself in literature, individuals develop the cognitive, analytical, and critical thinking skills necessary to comprehend and engage with complex subjects such as Philosophy, Psychology, Political Science, and beyond. Through the exploration of literary texts and the insights they offer into the human experience, young individuals gain a deeper understanding of humanity, morality, and social dynamics. Moreover, literary education fosters empathy and emotional intelligence, enabling young minds to navigate the complexities of the world with compassion and a nuanced perspective. Hollander posits that it’s through the study of literature that the young are empowered to become well-rounded, intellectually curious individuals who’re prepared to contribute meaningfully to society and tackle the challenges of a rapidly evolving world.

Scroll to Top